Tarrytown Roofing
2026-09-24T17:19:09.409Z
I originally reached out to Tarrytown Roofing after a neighbor with hail damage recommended them. My initial experience was actually very positive. The agent, Robert, did a great inspection he was cordial, professional, and took the time to share a lot of helpful information. He provided an initial quote right on the spot, though it was quite high.As I shopped around, other companies reached out with revised, competitive quotes to earn my business. When I found a strong offer and was about to sign, Robert suddenly started texting and calling, adamant that Tarrytown could beat my best price.This is where the entire experience derailed. I have sent probably 5 to 6+ texts explicitly asking Robert to send me their new numbers so I could compare them side-by-side. Instead of providing the quote, Robert constantly beats around the bush, blatantly refusing to send any actual numbers while stubbornly standing by his claim that he can beat the competitor's price. If I had to guess, Tarrytown themselves would be cutting corners on the materials or installation to get to that lower price point, and they simply don't want to show me the itemized quote because I would immediately see exactly how those corners are being cut.If Tarrytown respectfully cannot beat a competitor's numbers, a reputable business would just say so. Instead, they string you along, claim they have a better price, refuse to prove it, and then bizarrely tell you to just go with the other company anyway. I’ve had other roofers come out, and while they all had their own pricing quirks, they were at least honest about their bottom line and backed it up by actually sending me their numbers.To make matters worse, this lack of transparency seems to reflect a deeply unprofessional culture from the top down. During my dealings with them, I learned that the president of the company sent an internal email essentially belittling a homeowner in a "professional" way, dismissing the customer's legitimate concerns as a "story that takes a life of its own." I was assured this issue was addressed, the president is still with the company, and Robert thought it wouldn't happen again. Yet, here I am experiencing the exact same dismissive, manipulative behavior from Robert himself.Add their subpar warranties to the mix, and their pitch completely falls apart. Tarrytown’s workmanship and gutter warranties cap out at just 5 years. Yes, it's backed by an independent third party, but it's still the worst coverage out of every company I spoke with competitors were easily offering 10 to 15 years. If this is the level of transparency and service they offer, I could never recommend them
I originally reached out to Tarrytown Roofing after a neighbor with hail damage recommended them. My initial experience was actually very positive. Th... More